A major shift is needed
from increasingly expensive management of end-stage
disease to early detection and aggressive intervention.
Early intervention to slow the progression of disease
and delay the appearance of morbid events should be
considered. Data reviewed by Cohn suggest that screening
a healthy population will exhibit a high prevalence
of covert and overt disease that is not adequately treated
in the community; that the current health care system
does not provide early detection strategies; and in
the United States as well as in Japan a national program
aimed at early detection could strikingly reduce morbidity
and health care costs. |
|
Natural History
of Cardiovascular Disease |
Structural remodeling processes of the vasculature
and heart underlie most of the clinical events that
treatment aims to prevent. Improved understanding
of the contributors to these structural processes,
such as endothelial dysfunction and neurohormonal
activation, is needed. The atherosclerotic process,
the predominant factor in the vasculature, is partly
genetic and partly environment; factors that contribute
to endothelial dysfunction, which in turn is prerequisite
for the development of atherosclerosis. The atherosclerotic
process leads to the cardiovascular (CV) events that
mostly occur in the Western world.
Aging is a known contributor to atherosclerosis,
which smoking aggravates. Elevated blood pressure,
elevated LDL, low HDL, diabetes and oxidative stress
injure the endothelium. Once injured, an increase
in blood pressure and in the LDL-HDL ratio, and perhaps
inflammation, contribute to progression of the atherosclerotic
process. These represent a number of therapeutic targets
to slow this atherosclerotic process.
The manifestations
of large artery disease are seen after atherosclerosis
develops: widening pulse pressure, increased pulse
wave velocity, reduced large artery elasticity. All
are markers for disease in the large conduit artery
wall and is preceded by a reduction of small artery
elasticity, which appears to be a marker for endothelial
dysfunction, providing a method for early identification
of alterations of the endothelium that lead to the
progressive atherosclerotic process and places the
patient in the cardiovascular continuum.
|
PAGE
TOP
|
Genes and environment contribute to endothelial dysfunction
and diabetes, and may contribute to myocardial disease.
Hypertension develops at least in part as a manifestation
of the endothelial dysfunction and contributes to
myocardial disease. Left ventricular (LV) dysfunction,
remodeling of the left ventricle, and progressive
heart failure are natural evolutions of myocardial
disease. Atherosclerosis, a systemic disease that
leads to claudication, stroke, renal failure and coronary
disease, may occur very early. Endothelial dysfunction
is thought to contribute to nitric oxide deficiency
in all of the structural remodeling processes in the
left ventricle and vasculature and contributes to
hypertension. The renin angiotensin system (RAS) contributes
to progressive remodeling of the left ventricle, the
atherosclerotic process and hypertension. The balance
between the RAS and the nitric oxide system may be
critical to define the early progression of cardiac
and vascular disease that is termed the cardiovascular
continuum.
|
PAGE
TOP
|
The syndrome of heart failure has provided the opportunity
to conduct rather careful studies of the natural history
of the disease. The structural remodeling process,
which occurs after disease has influenced LV function,
leads to progressive enlargement of the chamber and
a reshaping of the chamber to a larger transverse
diameter. This process involves myocyte growth, lengthening
of the myocytes due to sarcomere growth in series,
and a change in the interstitium to allow the myocytes
to enlarge.
An enlarged chamber and reduced ejection fraction
result from matrix and myocyte changes. The falling
ejection fraction observed in progressive heart failure
is in large part a manifestation of a remodeling of
the chamber, not necessarily of contractile dysfunction.
The hormonal system is thought to be critically involved
in this process since it is activated in most patients
studied. Plasma norepinephrine, plasma renin activity,
arginine vasopressin, atrial and natriuretic peptide
and B-type natriuretic peptides are increased and
endothelin-1 levels are elevated persons with heart
failure compared to age matched, normal subjects.
Most of these hormones are important factors causing
vasoconstriction and thus increasing impedance to
left ventricular ejection, and causing growth and
remodeling of the myocytes and the interstitium.
|
PAGE
TOP
|
In the CONSENSUS I trial patients presenting with
hormone levels (norepinephrine, angiotensin II, aldosterone,
atrial natriuretic peptide) above the median had a
much higher mortality than those who presented with
hormone levels below the median. Norepinephrine, angiotensin
II and aldosterone are thought to contribute to disease
progression, which has led to the hypothesis that
LV dysfunction is associated with neurohormonal stimulation,
which raises impedance to LV ejection and further
impairs the function of the left ventricle. A vicious
circle ensues that makes the left ventricle progressively
worse. This neurohormonal stimulation also leads
to ventricular remodeling with myocyte and matrix
growth, further aggravating the neurohormonal stimulation
and LV dysfunction. The structural remodeling is the
major determinant of the long-term poor outcome in
patients with heart failure.
|
PAGE
TOP
|
Growing evidence points to the RAS as responsible
for most of the adverse effects of the progressive
structural process in the left ventricle and probably
in the vasculature. Renin angiotensin, a potent constrictor,
raises impedance and is a potent mitogen for stimulating
the remodeling process in the left ventricle and vasculature.
Angiotensin II has a series of deleterious effects
in the vasculature and heart. It is a potent vasoconstrictor,
activates other hormonal systems which may be equally
adverse in patients with heart failure, and is a potent
stimulator of myocyte growth, vascular smooth muscle
growth, and collagen synthesis; all components of
the remodeling process in the vasculature and heart.
Furthermore, it stimulates oxidative stress, platelet
aggregation and thrombosis. The potent adverse effects
of angiotensin II may play a role in the progressive
cardiovascular continuum, not only in heart failure
as a late manifestation.
The remodeling of the vasculature is less well
understood. Small arteries remodel and hence reduce
the lumen size, although smooth muscle mass is not
increased. The remodeling process in the small artery
raises impedance, resistance to flow and blood pressure.
Vascular smooth muscle grows and the vascular wall
will thickens as a result of an increase in smooth
muscle mass due to activation of the growth stimulating
effects of the renin angiotensin system. The rise
in resistance and wall thickness reduces arterial
elasticity and contributes to the impedance of the
LV ejection.
Vascular structure and vascular tone can be viewed
as dependent on the balance between the constrictor
growth promotion of angiotensin II and the dilation
and growth inhibitor effects of nitric oxide. The
reduction of nitric oxide levels or increase of angiotensin
II levels at the vascular site accelerates the abnormality
of tone and structure of the blood vessel and contributes
to the events that occur.
|
PAGE
TOP
|
Differences
in Large and Small Arteries |
The remodeling process in the artery wall appears
to be different in the large and small arteries. In
the large arteries, the lumen size actually tends
to increase, the wall becomes thicker, and the compliance
or distensibility of the large arteries is reduced.
As a result of this process, a consequence of endothelial
dysfunction, there is lipid accumulation and plaque
formation in the large conduit arteries that leads
to acute events.
In the small arteries, compliance or elasticity
of the small arteries is reduced. Flow inhibition
and impairment of regional blood flow occurs because
of the narrowing of the small nutritional arteries
in the microcirculation. A growing body of data suggests
that drugs that inhibit the renin angiotensin system
(ACE inhibitors, angiotensin receptor blockers) will
slow the progressive structural process occurring
in the wall of the large and small arteries. Data
from the SOLVD trial, in which left ventricular volume
was monitored, show that enalapril produced a significant
reduction in LV end diastolic and end systolic volume,
compared to placebo. Data from the carvedilol trial
conducted in Australia and New Zealand show that the
LV volume increased in the placebo arm, but fell in
the carvedilol group.
|
PAGE
TOP
|
Improved
Outcomes follow Structural Improvement |
The favorable structural effect appears to be directly
correlated with an improvement in outcome. The V-HeFT
trials, in which ejection fraction as a surrogate
for chamber dimension was monitored, showed that the
changes in LV ejection fraction correlated very well
with subsequent outcome. Mortality was very high in
patients whose ejection fraction fell by more than
five units during the study period. A lower rate of
mortality was seen when the ejection fraction remained
the same, an even lower mortality when the ejection
fraction rose by more than five units, and a strikingly
reduced mortality when the ejection fraction rose
by more than 10 units.
Improvement in the structural abnormality is associated
with an improved outcome; drugs with a favorable effect
on structural remodeling have a favorable effect on
outcome. Mortality was reduced with enalapril compared
to placebo in the CONSENSUS trial and the SOLVD treatment
trial, and in the post-MI trials (SAVE, AIRE, and
TRACE). Ramipril reduced the event rate in patients
with atherosclerotic disease or diabetes in the HOPE
trial. ACE inhibitors protect the arterial vasculature
and protect the left ventricle. Beta blockers produced
a significant improvement in survival compared to
placebo in the CIBIS II, MERIT-HF and Copernicus studies
providing clear evidence that favorable structural
effects on the left ventricle are associated with
favorable outcomes.
Angiotensin contributes to the progression of disease
in the setting of heart failure, even in the presence
of therapy, as shown by the results from the ValHeFT
trial. In patients with advanced heart failure on
standard background therapy, valsartan, compared to
placebo, produced a significant reduction in morbidity
and mortality; a 13.3% risk reduction compared to
placebo, added to background therapy, and a highly
significant 27.5% reduction in the risk for hospitalization
for adjudicated heart failure. All secondary markers
were improved with valsartan, including an improvement
in quality of life. Valsartan improved ejection fraction
and LV dimensions and lowered norepinephrine and BNP.
|
PAGE
TOP
|
The Case
for Earlier Intervention |
Mortality was not reduced in the ValHeFT trial. This
may be due to the late initiation of treatment, after
patients have a dilated left ventricle and low ejection
fraction and are clearly advanced in the cardiovascular
continuum. Late intervention, as in the clinical trials,
aims to delay the development of events. Instead,
monitoring should begin earlier in the biological
process to demonstrate a shift in the slope of the
progression of disease. The biological process may
involve structure of the left ventricle or arterial
vasculature or endothelial dysfunction, neurohormonal
activation, particularly the renin angiotensin system,
and probably gene expression. Early disease detection
provides the opportunity to slow the progressive diseases
of atherosclerosis and LV dysfunction. Therapeutic
intervention can slow progression in advanced disease
like heart failure, renal failure and post-myocardial
infarction.
Delaying disease progression should delay the occurrence
of morbid events. This intuitive concept remains to
be proven. The delay of morbid events should improve
quality of life and delay health care costs. Society
then might have to make some decision about age-related
health care responsibility, because while interventions
slow progression they do not necessarily halt progression,
so disease may occur at a later age. The cost-benefit-risk
ratio in specific population groups must be evaluated
to mount the effort to identify disease early.
|
PAGE
TOP
|
Program at
Rasmussen Center |
The Rasmussen Center at the University of Minnesota
is evaluating the effect of earlier intervention.
Screening tests for early detection of disease are
performed in healthy persons who are self-referred
to learn whether they are at risk for cardiovascular
events. Testing that provides markers for early blood
vessel disease, early heart disease, and risk contributors
for intervention is performed. A two-hour screening
procedure, nearly all non-invasive, includes a vascular
evaluation with the measurement of arterial elasticity
of both the small and large arteries. Blood pressure
is measured at rest and during a three-minute treadmill
exercise test at five METS workload. A digital photograph
of the retina to evaluate the vasculature directly
is taken. A urine test for the microalbumin-creatinine
ratio is conducted and a Doppler measurement of the
ankle brachial index.
The cardiac evaluation includes an electrocardiogram,
an ultrasound of the left ventricle for measurement
of chamber dimension and wall thickness (hand-held
ultrasound evaluation), measurement of the plasma
BNP level as a further index to left ventricular remodeling,
and a forced vital capacity for ventilatory function.
A series of modifiable disease contributors is also
measured: fasting lipid levels, LDL, HDL, triglyceride,
fasting blood sugar, HS-CRP, homocysteine and PAI-1.
Other markers of cardiovascular disease are: normal,
borderline, and abnormal blood pressures at rest and
exercise; the vasculature in the optic fundus; the
presence of microalbumin; the ankle brachial index;
the electrocardiogram; the ultrasound, measurement
of the left ventricular dimension and LV mass; body
surface area ratio; and BNP levels.
The measurement of elasticity is an important
component of the screening process, using a technique
developed at the University of Minnesota. A transducer
is placed on the wrist and records the waveform from
the radial artery. The waveform is analyzed statistically
to solve a third order equation dividing the diastolic
decay recorded into two components, an exponential
decay (largely dependent on the large artery elasticity
or compliance) and an oscillatory wave form (largely
dependent on the reflected waves or oscillations,
formed in the more distal, small arteries). This technique
allows evaluation separately of large and small artery
elasticity. Elasticity is reduced progressively with
age, and is lower in females than in males.
The results from the first 333 persons screened
indicate that those already on the cardiovascular
continuum were identified. Elevated blood pressure
was present in many and surprising number had an abnormal
exercise treadmill test. Borderline abnormalities
were seen in many. The ankle brachial index was not
very discriminating. A remarkable number of people
without diabetes and without known disease had microalbuminuria,
indicating mall artery disease in the kidney. Abnormal
LV dimension or wall thickness was identified.
The benefits to early screening for disease are:
identification of undetected and untreated advanced
disease; evidence to support efforts at lifestyle
modification, if indicated; provide data for establishing
the rate of progression in an asymptomatic population;
the potential to improve quality and duration of organ
system disease-free life.
|
PAGE
TOP
|
Report
Index | Previous Report
| Next Report
Scientific
Sessions | Activities
| Publications
Index
Copyright © 2002
Japanese Circulation Society
All Rights Reserved.
webmaster@j-circ.or.jp
|